I think it'd be nice to have a whole set of possible messages, each associated with some equation which has zero on the right hand side. It'd look something like this:
"404; Did you just [insert operation that yields zero*]? Because there's nothing here! (Insert relevant equation**)"
*Examples; (**Corresponding equations):
1. symmetrize the electromagnetic field strength tensor (F(μν)=0)
2. take a covariant derivative of the metric (∇ρgμν=0)
3. calculate a lightlike interval (ds2=0)
4. vary the action of the internet (δS=0)
5. take the d'Alembertian of a massless field (◻ϕ=0)
6. check the Bianchi identities (∇[μFνσ]=0) or (∇[μRνσ]=0)
feel free to add other/better ones if you'd like