Physics Overflow is a question & answer site for physics (including theoretical, experimental, and phenomenology) at the graduate-level and above. Beyond this, there is also a reviews section where papers from ArXiV are automatically imported to Physics Overflow by a bot, and papers from other databases can be manually be added (probably by a plugin) for reviewing. Other users may add comments on the paper, or review the paper. The questions and answers are votable, as they are on the main site.
There is also a meta where you can discuss the site itself, including bugs, feature requests, support requests, community moderation, and discussion in general.
The chat room is intended for discussions that are not stricty on-topic in the other sections, but are still considered to be of interest to the community. For instance,
This part of PhysicsOverflow is meant to be some kind of a revival of Theoretical Physics SE with a slightly lowered (graduate-level upward) bar to ask and quite a broadend scope. Basically, all graduate-level upward Physics is on-topic here.
On-topic questions in this section include:
Examples of off-topic topics include:
The Reviews section is devoted to open refereeing, defending and discussing of physics papers.
This review system works best, if people vote only when they feel they have an insight regarding the topic, and understand the material well enough to make a decision regarding the subject matter. Optimally, up and downvotes concerning the accuracy and originality of the papers are accompanied by detailed explanatory (supporting or critical) reviews and comments respectively, such that the present judgement of the paper by the PhysicsOverflow community is transparent and motivated by physics arguments. Also, votes can be changed later if needed.
We maintain a completely open and transparent reject-to-review policy. Papers are usually accepted for open community review, however, they may be rejected in certain situations. Click to view larger version.
The Reviews section will be structured by the well known ArXiv physics categories supplemented by a hierachial category system. This system is implemented, but recategorising of existing papers would take some time.
We use a fork of Question2Answer v1.6.2 with the following standard Q2A-provided plug-ins:
The following external plug-ins:
The theme that we use the PhysicsOversnow (officially PO-theme) by polarkernel which is based on the Snow theme by Q2A market.
We use CKEditor v1.4 for our editor and the default Q2A search widget for our search bar.Below are some differences from the SE software:
Stack Exchange | Physics Overflow (Q2A) | |
Comment Voting | Only positive | Positive and Negative |
Vote Counts | Net score displayed[1] | Vote counts displayed |
Downvote rep change | A fifth or two of upvotes | Same as upvotes |
Accepting answers | Yes[2] | Disabled |
Approve suggested edit | 2 users needed | 1 user enough |
Editor | Markdown Editor | WYSIWYG editor |
Autodeletion | Inactive questions auto-deleted | Questions never auto-deleted |
Comment length | $\leq$ 600 characters | Almost unlimited |
Ping Detection | Only if they have been involved in a thread, and some confusing restrictions; one user can be pinged per comment | Pings all user mentions; Advanced pinging (see section 23) system |
Vote Reversal | Users can reverse their votes only till 5 minutes after voting | Users can always reverse their votes |
Vote and Rep caps | Vote and Rep caps exist; serial voting automatically reversed | No vote and rep caps exist; serial voting reversed by moderators for complete accuracy in detecting serial votes |
[1]: Users with at least 1k rep, or who have installed a userscript, may click on net score to see vote counts
[2]: The idea of accepting answers was completely unnecessary as the decision gives the false impression that the accepted answer is really the best.
See History of Physics Overflow
Physics Stack Exchange is a general physics Q&A library for physics at all levels, while PhysicsOverflow is an academic platform for open peer review and a postgraduate-level discussion forum . Requests for resource recommendations and other topics of general interest to the international academic physics community are welcome on PhysicsOverflow, whereas on Physics Stack Exchange this kind of question (on MathOverflow they are tagged as soft-questions) is highly restricted and mostly off-topic.
Quora is a general Q&A site, and the physics section is not restricted by level or scope, and more targetted towards popular science.
MathsOverflow is primarily a research-level mathematics site, even though mathematical physics is allowed.
TheoreticalPhysics.SE was a site only for research-level theoretical physics. PhysicsOverflow's Q&A section is some sort of a revival of TheoreticalPhysics.SE, but with a much broader scope. We accept not only Theoretical Physics, but also Experimental Physics, Astronomy, and Phenomenology. Our scope is also more broad, since our scope is not exclusively research-level, but graduate-level and above.
All the questions from Theoretical Physics Stack Exchange have been imported into PhysicsOverflow, and all the graduate-level ones on Physics Stack Exchange will soon be.
PhysicsOverflow.com was a SE-1.0 site which was later taken over by Physics Stack Exchange. It was mostly populated with sub-graduate-level questions. It is not affilated in any way with PhysicsOverflow.
Go the answer form below the question:
Then type your answer in the exact same way that you would type a question.
Click the "comment" button beneath a post:
Enter your comment the same way you would enter a question or an answer, and then, post it.
Indeed, posts on Physics Overflow are editable. If you have more than 500 reputation points, you can edit a post (questions, comments, answers, everything!) directly, by clicking the "edit" button below the post.
If you have less than 500 reputation points, then you can click the suggest edits button which has the same icon as the edit button.
You can then follow the instructions given on the site there (expand the instructions) to suggest a new edit to the post. Someone with editing permissions will review the edit and perform it for you.
Posts in the "Recommendations" category should be edited to include the text "[RECOMENDATION]" in the title.
Posts may be edited for readability or to make them more direct. However, keep in mind that the OP's user rights still apply, in that the OP has the final say regarding the appropriateness of your edit. Civility is strongly encouraged but will never be enforced.
Here are some guidelines on editing (note that they're not hard rules, and that you should generally use your common sense in editing a post)
If you are a contributor whose text was edited, and you don't like the edit, it is often better to improve it further in the light of the corrections made than to undo it, which is usually appropriate only in case the edit changes the scientific meaning of the post.
Users with less than 500 reputation cannot do any of those. However, they can still help out by downvoting and flagging bad posts.
The following instructions apply to users with at least 500 reputation.
If you spot a bad or off-topic question, then help us moderate the site by voting to close it. Below the question, you will find a button that says "vote to close"
Click it. You will be lead to a page on which you can propose the question to be closed. If the suggestion to close the question already exists, you can just upvote the existing suggestion.
When the suggestion (whether it is yours, or someone elses), reaches a net score of +2, the question will be closed by a moderator.
The same holds for reopening. If you feel that a question has been wrongly closed, then you may click the "vote to reopen" button under it, which will lead you to a page, where you may propose that the question be reopened.
If the suggestion (yours or existing) reaches a net score of +2, the question will be reopened by a mod.
Go here. Then do the same.
Go here. Then do the same.
Reputation points are a rough measure of your contribution to the site (this is not to say, however, that participating on meta doesn't help the site. Of course it does.). It helps decide the permissions you get.
(no reputation change)
You can also earn reputation by winning a bounty.
You can also lose reputation by giving away a bounty.
The following are the permissions ("priviledges") you get with rep or whatever. Note that every user group in a third-level heading also has the permissions of the user group in the previous third-level heading of the same second-level heading, and that every user group in a fourth-level heading also has the permissions of the previous fourth-level heading in the same third-level heading.
Bounties are a way of promoting a particular question you find interesting. Instructions here.
Basically, you offer some of your reputation points so that someone answers a particular question. You choose the answer which you like best by linking to it on the bounties page. If you don't choose the answer within one day after the time limit you have specified, the bounty will be awarded to the most upvoted answer.
Tag wikis, or tag descriptions, are descriptions of tags on tag pages. They can only be edited by experts, moderators, administrators, and super-administrators. However, any user may suggest an edit on them. They are called tag "wikis" for historical reasons - the tag descriptions used to be hosted on an external, editable wiki.
There are four navigation bars on Physics Overflow, in addition to a footer.
Note: To users with JavaScript disabled, the HeadBar and the Admin Bar do not appear and their contents appear as a part of the NavBar.
The top-most bar contains account-related matters, link to Moderation (usable by 500+ rep users only), and a search widget.
On the left-most (in red), there is a link to one's user profile.
Next, (in blue), one's total reputation on Physics Overflow is written.
Next, there is a link to edit one's account details, user profile, and so on.
This is followed by a list of one's updates, which is less comprehensive than the User History which can be found on the SubNavBar of one's profile page.
The HeadBar is the bar in the header, next to the logo.
The Admin Bar contains the "Search User" link and all the tools that are not available to anonymous users, including:
The NavBar contains many links that can be seen by all users, listed below:
The SubNavBar is used to list subpages, etc. of a particular page. It is found only on certain pages, e.g. user pages, the questions page, and the admin panel. On the users page, it contains the following links on the user pages:
The questions page contains the following subpages in the SubNavBar:
The Admin Panel does not need further documentation.
The footer is not a navigation bar, but it contains a link to a form to contact the site's Super-Administrators privately, and a link to the Question2Answer (the software that we use) official website, and a note saying that the theme used is "OverSnow", short for "Physics OverSnow" by polarkernel, based on the standard Snow theme.
If you have 500 reputation points, you may help Physics Overflow further by helping out in Community Moderation. From the Navigation Bar, click "Moderate":
You will be lead to this page. There, you can help with the following tasks:
For each task, click on the link to see the review page, together with the instructions.
Downvote the question and flag it. A moderator will attend to your flag and put it up in the queue. Your identity will not be revealed. If many people agree with your flag, the question will be closed.
Same thing. Downvote the post and flag it. A moderator will attend to your flag and put it up in the queue. Your identity will not be revealed. If many people agree with your flag, the post will be deleted.
Downvote the question and Vote to Close it by clicking the "Vote to Close" Button. You will be directed here. Check if the question has already been reported, and if it is, then upvote the proposal to close it. If not, then write a new answer linking to the question. If your proposal reaches a net score of +2, the question will be closed.
Downvote the post. Copy the URL of the post. If it is an answer, you can click on "answered" below the post content and you will get the URL. Then in the White Navigation Bar, click on "Moderate".
Select "Review Delete Votes":
Then do the same as what you would do to vote to close a question.
While the moderators are supposed to exercise the will of the community at all costs, in case you feel that they make a mistake (which does not violate any conservation laws, so this has a non-zero probability of occuring.), Make a post on meta condemning the action. Other people will add comments to the post, and if enough people agree, the moderator decision will be overruled by the community.
If the moderator decision is outright ridiculous (e.g. banning an extremely important contributor to the site, or coming up with niceness rules), there could be a vote whether the moderator is to retain their moderatorship any longer.
If you have at least 500 reputation, and disagree with the closure of a question, then you can vote to reopen it.
If you don't have enough reputation, make a post about it on meta.
In this case you can use flags or write an email to admin@physicsoverflow.org. The issue will then be treated in strict confidence by the PhysicsOverflow team
If you want to recieve updates each time
Just go to the question, tag, category, or user 's page, and click the Star on the top right.
If you participated on the Theoretical Physics Stack Exchange, or the Physics Stack Exchange, then your posts may already have been imported, so you may already have an account on Physics Overflow. Please search for your account to check if this is the case.
Enter your username, and press "Search".
If you are lead to your profile, your account exists. Then you can regain access to your imported account. To do so, click on "Regain SE account" in the sidebar sidebox. Now, follow the instructions there, and choose your preferred way of getting access to your account.
If you never had an SE account, or never had graduate-level posts on SE, just register as a new user.
All the questions from Theoretical Physics Stack Exchange have been imported, as they fall into the "graduate-level" category.
Most questions from Physics Stack Exchange in high-level tags which are not taggable as popular-science are theoretically eligible for import, and are given priority if they are endangered, very high-level, or spotted early.
Some such questions are listed here and here in the blog.
The final procedure in the long run is to list questions that should be imported on the Request for import votes thread, accessible from the top menu bar.
Inappropriate questions (imported or not) can be listed in the corresponding community moderation threads (they mimic the review queues of SE) accessible from the link Moderate in the top menu bar.
The copyright issues have been taken care of, since Stack Exchange is CC-by-SA content, and we have attributed them, and are not a commercial for-profit. For more information see the page Attributions.
You are generally permitted to make your own posts native (i.e. remove the attribution line) if the criteria mentioned here are met.
User contributions on PhysicsOverflow are all licensed under CC-BY-SA-3.0 as stated at the bottom of every page.
If using user-generated content from PhysicsOverflow, please be sure to clearly state that the content is from PhysicsOverflow, link to the post, clearly state the username of the poster of the content, link to the user's user page, mention the time at which the post's content was taken (correct to the nearest minute, and with time zone specified), and a link to PhysicsOverflow. For example,
This post imported from PhysicsOverflow at 2014-03-30 15:47 (UCT), posted by SE-user physicsnewbieIn a research paper, report, etc., the following citation style is acceptable, (\(\mathrm{Bib}\TeX \))
@MISC {4657, TITLE = {FAQ for Physics Overflow}, AUTHOR = {dimension10 (http://www.physicsoverflow.org/user/dimension10 )}, HOWPUBLISHED = {PhysicsOverflow}, NOTE = {URL:http://www.physicsoverflow.org/4657 (version: 2014-03-21)}, EPRINT = {http://www.physicsoverflow.org/4657}, URL = {http://www.physicsoverflow.org/4657} }
For answers, use the title of the question.
To find the permalink to a post (question/answer/comment), click on the "asked"/"answered"/"commented" button. You may end up with a URL like this one:
http://physicsoverflow.org/15259/how-does-locality-decouple-the-uv-and-ir-behaviour-of-a-qft?show=15447#a15447
It is enough to use the shortened form of the URL:
http://physicsoverflow.org/15259#a15447
I.e. remove the question title and the ?show parameter with it's value from the URL if you want a short URL.
You may search PhysicsOverflow from the top-right search bar.
Alternatively, you my use PhysicsOverfind, a Google Custom Search.
When someone comments on your post, answers your question, pings you, votes on your post, etc. you will see a small number (in a yellow background) beside your username in the top-bar.
It will lead to your history page. For example, if your username is John Doe, you will be lead to this page. The unread notifications appear highlighted.
Note: This may occassionally have some rendering problems with WebKit-based browsers such as Chrome, Opera, and Safari. If you do not see notifications, try the following:
To alert a user, please use the "@" command and remove spaces from the username, example, the user "John Doe" should be pinged as "@JohnDoe", while the user "Johndoe" should be pinged as "@JohnDoe". The post author is always automatically pinged (unless you are the post author).
PhysicsOverflow supports MathJax for \(\LaTeX\) support.
You may click the "\(\TeX\)" button in the editor to enter LaTeX as described here. However, you may also type equations between dollar signs for inline mathematics and double-dollar signs for block equations.
For a more detailed tutorial on MathJax, please see this post.
user contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required
Your rights